Shuichiro Ogawa
日本語

Notes

Research, experiments, and reflections on AI and design, published along with the process of making them.

Back to the monthly list

Design theory and history (23)

What design is, seen through theory and the history of the field.

  • Researchers and Designers to Know Before Discussing the Philosophy of Design: Comparing Who Carries the Debate Worldwide and in Japan

    2026-10-24

    This note lists the researchers and designers a reader should know before joining a discussion of the philosophy of design, divided into the world and Japan, and compares who carries the debate in each. Worldwide, the figures fall into five positions: the design methods movement and its critics (Alexander, Jones, Archer, Rittel, Simon), the self-understanding of design research (Schön, Cross, Buchanan, Krippendorff), philosophy of technology and STS (Kroes, Houkes and Vermaas, Latour, Verbeek), entries from philosophy and aesthetics (Flusser, Parsons, Vial, Love, Galle), and critique and justice (Papanek, Maldonado, Fry, Dunne and Raby, Manzini, Escobar), with venues such as the Design Studies special issue, Design Philosophy Papers, and the reader edited by Willis. In Japan, the carriers fall into six lineages that do not cite one another: Yoshikawa's general design theory, Mukai's basic design studies, Nagamachi's kansei engineering, Yanagi's mingei, the writings of Hara, Fukasawa, and Kurokawa, and entries by Sasaki, Kashiwagi, and Monnai. The comparison shows that in Japan, entries from philosophers are thin, engineers and designers take the philosophical role, and the reception of Simon, Schön, Norman, Krippendorff, and Alexander was carried by engineering, education, cognitive science, and designers' associations. 127 references (78 newly added and 49 inherited).

  • Essential Readings for Researching the Philosophy of Design in the Age of AI (A Guide by Current)

    2026-10-23

    This note selects, current by current, the literature that a researcher starting work on the philosophy of design in the age of AI should read to understand the currents that came before, and it proposes a reading order. Each of the questions that AI is now reopening (who makes the judgment, what designers know, how designed things change the actions of their users, and whose world design makes) was raised in some earlier text. For each current, the note therefore pairs the texts that raised a question with recent work that applies the question to AI. Because the philosophy of design has no reading list fixed by editors or societies, the selection follows three criteria: a text first raised a question that later currents presuppose, overview texts cite it as foundational, and recent work on AI actually builds on it. During the selection, it became clear that design research and the philosophy of technology cite different classics. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on the philosophy of technology cites Simon, Winner, Latour, Verbeek, Houkes and Vermaas, and Kroes, but not Schön, Cross, Buchanan, Rittel, Galle, Winograd, or Suchman. The note divides the literature into six currents: the attempt to make design scientific and the reaction to it (Simon, Cross, Rittel and Webber, Schön, Buchanan); the two paths that appeared when computers and design met in the 1980s (the hermeneutic critique by Winograd and Flores, and the formalization of design in Hiroyuki Yoshikawa's general design theory); the formation of the philosophy of design around 2000 (Love, Galle, the dual nature of technical artifacts by Kroes and Meijers, and the use plan theory of Houkes and Vermaas); the line in the philosophy of technology and STS holding that artifacts shape actions (Akrich's script, Latour's delegation, Verbeek's mediation and design ethics, and Ihde's human-technology relations); ontological designing, which holds that design makes worlds (Willis, Escobar); and the work asking whom design serves and what lies beyond human-centeredness (critical design, design justice, posthumanism). On the AI side, the note pairs these with Yang and colleagues on why human-AI interaction is difficult to design, Benjamin and colleagues on a post-phenomenology of machine learning uncertainty, van de Poel on embedding values in AI systems, Gal on the aesthetics of generative AI, Abdipour on authorship, and Vogel and Quadflieg and Heron and colleagues on how generative AI forecloses futures. The note ends with a reading order of 12 items that moves from short, accessible papers to books.

  • How Have Network Science and Design Studies Related to Each Other? (Academic Research)

    2026-10-11

    This note examines, through the literature, the relationship between network science and design studies from three angles: how design research has used network methods, how network science has used the word "design", and where the two meet and where they reach their limits. The two lines of work start from the same question in the 1960s, namely how to divide a complex whole into parts. Simon argued that hierarchic systems are nearly decomposable, with stronger linkages within parts than between them. Alexander presented a method that represented design requirements as a graph and partitioned it, and then moved away from that method by arguing that a naturally grown city is a semilattice, not a tree. Since then, design research has mainly used networks as tools for representing and measuring structure: the links between product components and organizations (DSM; a review of 142 empirical studies of the mirroring hypothesis found mirroring to be common but not universal), the design process (linkography, semantic networks of design protocols), urban streets (space syntax, the centrality of street networks), and teams and the field itself (a co-citation analysis of 12,107 citations in 459 Design Studies papers from 1996 to 2010). On the network science side, in the literature collected here, "design" mainly refers to optimization under constraints. It is discussed as the design principles of biological networks that have no designer (network motifs, modularity that emerges under changing goals) and as the difference between designed and self-organized systems (HOT, and an experiment in which a slime mold builds a network comparable to the Tokyo rail network). The two fields come closest in the drawing of networks: layout aesthetics have been tested against human reading (reducing edge crossings matters most), and force-directed drawings retain ambiguity. As limits, a test on nearly 1,000 networks did not support the universality of scale-free structure, the topological representation of space syntax has been criticized for discarding metric information, and Latour warned that the "network" of actor-network theory is not a technical network. What design research borrowed from network science was mainly a set of tools for measuring structure, and the side of design that Rittel and Webber described as problems without a stopping rule, namely how designers define a problem, appears to have only begun to be addressed with network methods.

  • What Is the Philosophy of Design? (Academic Research)

    2026-10-11

    This note examines, through the literature, what the philosophy of design asks, where it came from, which currents it has passed through, and where it is heading. The philosophy of design announced itself as a young field around 2000, in articles and a special issue of Design Studies. Galle characterized it as the pursuit of insights about design by philosophical means, that is, by rational reflection rather than empirical observation. Love distinguished it from "design philosophy", a term tied to the study of design methods, and placed it alongside the philosophy of science and the philosophy of technology. The papers in the special issue dealt with conceptualizations of design, methodology, criteria for quality, the dual nature of technical artefacts (a physical structure and an intended function), and phenomenology. The field originated in two waves of attempts to make design scientific (the modernist search for objectivity in the 1920s and the design methods movement of the 1960s) and in the reaction against them. In the 1970s, some pioneers of the movement turned away from methods, Rittel and Webber called planning problems wicked problems that have no definitive formulation, and Schön criticized Simon's "science of design" for assuming well-formed problems. From there, Cross set up design as a discipline with its own forms of knowledge rather than as a science, and Buchanan argued that design should be recognized as a new liberal art of technological culture. From the 2000s, the object of inquiry widened from the designer's process to how designed things shape people and the world. Verbeek argued that because technologies coshape human actions, designers are doing ethics by other means, and ontological designing holds that design shapes the world and that this world in turn designs us. Critical design, design justice, transition design, and posthumanist and more-than-human design each question the assumptions of human-centeredness or universalism. On generative AI, the literature has begun to ask what happens when design decisions are substituted by machines (Verganti et al.), what is actually generated by generative AI (Bordas et al.), and whether generative AI makes design converge on a dominant way of knowing (Vogel and Quadflieg). The Design Philosophies track of DRS 2026 received 34 submissions, and six papers dealing with ontology, epistemology, cognition, ethics, and aesthetics remained in the track. Whether design knowledge requires a distinct epistemology is still contested between Cross's axiom and Digby's critical rationalism, which regards a separate epistemology as unnecessary. The 2026 volume edited by Secomandi and Verbeek discusses a shift from a "philosophy of design", in which philosophers discuss design from outside, toward "a designerly way of doing philosophy".

  • Does Design Need Its Own Epistemology, and Can Philosophy Be Done by Design? (Reading Two 2026 Texts)

    2026-10-11

    This note reads two texts published in 2026 in full, sets out the claims, argumentative steps, evidence, anticipated objections, and concepts of each, and examines where the two conflict and where they are compatible. Digby (DRS2026) argued that the dichotomies of design epistemology, such as science versus art and rationality versus intuition, are false dichotomies, and that the Critical Rationalism of Popper and Deutsch (knowledge is fallible conjecture and grows through error-correction by criticism) explains the distinctive features of design without a separate epistemology for design. Digby treated the accounts of Cross, Schön, and Dorst and Cross as descriptive, argued that pragmatism, constructivism, and phenomenology cannot explain objective progress, and regarded designs as explanatory theories about how to solve problems. The volume edited by Secomandi and Verbeek argued that design philosophy has undergone a technology turn over the past two decades (technology becomes the central theme, examined from the philosophy of technology proper), described humans as technologically mediated beings by design, and rejected the distrust of technology in ontological and pluriversal design by appealing to Hegel's mutual recognition. The phrase "a designerly way of doing philosophy," which the publisher's description presents as the editors' claim, comes in the body of the book from Chapter 7 by Eggink and Dorrestijn, who cite Cross 2001. The two texts do not cite each other, and Digby's reference list shares no work with the two chapters written by the editors (it shares only Dorst 2011 with Chapter 7). They conflict on two points: whether design philosophy is framed by the philosophy of science or by the philosophy of technology, and whether design failure is attributed to insufficient knowledge or to the imbalance of who designs for whom. They are compatible in treating design as fallible, in rejecting technological pessimism, and in testing ideas by making them into things. The full text of Galle 2018, which Digby cited for his starting diagnosis, does not contain the oscillation between scientism and relativism that Digby attributes to it, and defines design research as a specialization of research in general. Digby did not cite the Design Studies debate on whether science and design are the same kind of activity (Farrell and Hooker, Galle and Kroes), and did not answer the distinction drawn by Galle and Kroes, according to which scientific theories are evaluated by truth whereas design proposals are not. As of 11 October 2026, Digby had 0 citations and the volume had 1.

  • What Do the "X Fiction" Methods Think, and What Are They Expected to Do?

    2026-09-22

    This note reads academic work on science fiction prototyping, design fiction, critical and speculative design, diegetic prototypes, speculative fiction, experiential futures, and social fiction, asking three things: where each idea came from, how the ideas differ, and what adopters have expected of them. The names sound alike, but the origins are separate: SF and technology development (Johnson, Kirby), design critique at the RCA (Dunne and Raby), futures studies (Candy), and literary genre theory (Oziewicz). The largest difference is whether the fiction is meant to move toward production or to stay away from production and keep a question open. Johnson tied science fiction prototypes to fostering innovation, while Dunne and Raby named the opposite of critical design "affirmative design: design that reinforces the status quo." Adopters' expectations fall into five groups: organizational foresight, anticipation in responsible research and innovation (RRI), eliciting values in HCI, ethics education, and imagination by marginalized communities. A corporate design fiction project that drifted toward affirmative design (Ringfort-Felner et al. 2023) and the critique that speculative design stays inside galleries and privilege can both be read as a mismatch between these two directions. Evidence of effects is covered in sf-prototyping-design-fiction-effects-literature.

  • What Do Science Fiction Prototyping and Design Fiction Actually Do?

    2026-09-22

    This note reads 81 academic works on the "effects" of science fiction prototyping (Johnson 2011) and design fiction (Bleecker 2009), sorted into four settings: the route by which technology shown in films moves the real world, organizational foresight, HCI research tools, and education. What has mainly been established is that these methods can draw discussion and values out of participants. A deployment study of the HawkEye probe (Noortman et al. 2019) reports empathic discussion about the consequences of future technology, and a Detroit workshop that centered Afrofuturism (Dillahunt et al. 2023) drew alternative economic visions out of residents. By contrast, no study in this corpus compared effects on learning or organizations against a control group, and the only quantitative pre/post comparison is Nicholes (2020), which measured how 83 college students perceived writing. Studies also report that the criteria for evaluation are themselves unsettled (Baumer et al. 2020), that the pursuit of plausibility edges toward deception (Coulton et al. 2016), and that in a course meant to make students imagine critical futures, the students reproduced dominant views of technology (Rahm 2024).

  • Was the 'Absence of a Science of Design' Asserted Three Times? Rereading the Observations of 1978, 2008, and 2023 in Their Sources

    2026-08-31

    A rereading of the problem statement repeatedly invoked in design research in Japan, the 'absence of a science of design', against the three statements it rests on: Kimimasa Abe (1978), Shutaro Mukai, and Kazaru Yaegashi and colleagues (2023). The three are not saying the same thing. Abe asks about the standing of design as a discipline, whether it is no more than 'applied art'; Mukai judges that only the Ulm School of Design possessed a practical theory of designing, while leaving its reconstruction unfinished; Yaegashi and colleagues diagnose that the pursuit of scientization arrived at the paradox of 'the impossibility of scientization'. The question moves from standing to construction, and from construction to method. Then in 2025, Nigel Cross himself, on whom Yaegashi and colleagues rest, wrote that 'design is now recognized as an academic discipline', and declared in a co-authored paper that 'we have emerged'. As a problem statement, absence is no longer current as of 2026.

  • Submission Plan for the Bulletin of JSSD: Parallel Diagnoses of the Validity of Design as a Discipline

    2026-08-31

    A preparatory note that organizes the submission requirements, the paper concept, the theoretical framework, the gap in prior work, and the feasibility of the method, on the assumption of a submission to the Bulletin of JSSD (Dezaingaku Kenkyu), the journal of the Japanese Society for the Science of Design. The initial concept (asking about the mechanism by which the question of the absence of a science of design is not carried forward) lost its premise as a result of the survey. Yaegashi and colleagues (2023) have been carried forward through self-citation, the Encyclopedia of Design Science, supported by 16 academic societies and associations, was already published in 2019, and a joint symposium of 5 societies has continued since fiscal year 2016. What emerged instead is a structure in which diagnoses of the validity of design as a discipline do not connect with each other, although institutional frameworks for collaboration exist. The plan adopts Whitley's fragmented adhocracy as the framework and Vakkari's (2024) application to library and information science as the methodological precedent.

  • The Genealogy of Design Research in Japan: Three Origins, and the University That Passed the Presidency Around

    2026-08-31

    An integrative summary mapping design research in Japan across four layers: the founding genealogy of institutions (1876–2026), the branching of learned societies, theoretical schools, and the structure of faculty hiring. It draws on 94 sources: peer-reviewed papers and primary materials from universities, learned societies, and public agencies. The institutional forms of design education split into three origins (an engineering line, an aesthetics line, and a geijutsu kogaku line), each of which has its own learned society. The Japan Society for the Science of Design publishes no list of past presidents; reconstructing all 14 from the colophons of its journal shows that 6 of the 12 whose affiliation could be established were at Chiba University, and that a 1986 paper lists three future presidents as co-authors from the same laboratory. On faculty hiring, by contrast, the self-institution hiring rate for Japanese universities as a whole (32.6%, FY2013) is published, yet no figure specific to design exists anywhere. To fill that gap, the alma maters of faculty at three major institutions were tallied here: the self-institution rate ranges from 12.5% to 66.7% depending on the institution, and at the same time, at the institution with the highest rate, none of the faculty whose credentials could be confirmed hold a doctorate.

  • Recent Academic Topics in Design Research (2024–2026): A Literature Map and This Wiki's Position

    2026-08-09

    An integrative summary mapping 39 peer-reviewed publications (2024–2026) in design research / design studies into eight clusters: AI and design, methodology, the normative turn (sustainability / decoloniality / more-than-human), education, the profession, and the field's self-diagnosis, identifying where this wiki's holdings overlap with the field and where they leave gaps.

  • Connecting design theory and sociology: where does novelty get lost?

    2026-07-27

    To derive research questions from the areas where design theory and sociology have not been connected, we ran three generators with different methods in parallel and used their degree of convergence as an indirect indicator of novelty. Checking the primary literature and a second review by an academic critic rejected this indicator in two steps. First, the three generators shared the input corpus, so convergence measured salience rather than the independence of methods. Second, the candidates that failed all failed for the same reason, regardless of their degree of convergence: the general theories of sociology already included design practice within their scope. We made the demotion norm explicit in three stages and rescored the 15 candidates. The result was 10 of the covering type, 1 pending, 3 that stand after rewriting, and 2 of the symmetry-completion type (1 of which carries the reactivity of self-application). The note records, as a ledger, 15 integrated RQ candidates, 4 reverse contributions, 3 critiques of the author's own theory, and 52 unverified items.

  • A Genealogy of Practitioner Methods for Reframing Problems: Who Made Them, Traced to Their Origins

    2026-07-21

    An industry-side map of practitioner methods for problem setting, problem framing, and reframing, narrowed to their originators, primary sources, and standing in practice. It covers convergence/divergence process methods (Design Council's Double Diamond, IDEO/d.school's Design Thinking, GV's Design Sprint), question-posing/reframing methods (How Might We, de Bono's lateral thinking and Six Thinking Hats, First Principles, SCAMPER), structured-decomposition methods (TRIZ, morphological analysis, Toyota's Five Whys, McKinsey's seven-step process, Conn & McLean's Bulletproof, Minto's SCQA), and the three lineages of Jobs-to-be-Done (Ulwick/Christensen/Moesta). Where a method's origin is disputed, the note lists the competing accounts rather than asserting one, and treats promotional effectiveness figures as partial with their methodology attached. The gaps between academia and industry (IDEO is a propagator, not the originator, of HMW; First Principles offers no decision criterion; GMA and TRIZ have not penetrated practice, etc.) are organized at the end. A neutral practitioner review. References carry primary sources and official explanations.

  • An Academic Map of Methods for Reframing Problems: From Abduction-2 to Problem Structuring

    2026-07-21

    A literature map that surveys the methods of problem setting, problem framing, and reframing across peer-reviewed research and canon from design methodology, cognitive science, and systems thinking. Starting from Dorst's abduction-2 (frame creation), it connects, by lineage: functional fixedness and representational change in cognitive science (Duncker, Ohlsson, Kaplan & Simon, Chi); the psychology of problem finding and problem construction (Getzels & Csikszentmihalyi, Reiter-Palmon, Mumford); C-K theory and problem-solution co-evolution (Hatchuel & Weil, Maher & Tang, Wiltschnig); wicked problems and problem structuring methods (Rittel & Webber, Checkland SSM, Eden SODA, Rosenhead PSM, Ackoff); Cynefin (Kurtz & Snowden); morphological analysis (Zwicky, Ritchey); the theorization of TRIZ (Altshuller, Cavallucci); lateral thinking (de Bono); and empirical work on reframing in design (Valkenburg & Dorst, Paton & Dorst, Stompff). A neutral prior-work review. 38 references (bibliography reachability-confirmed and ISBNs fixed; remaining reservations collected at the end).

  • Justifying the Democratization of Design: A Literature Map of Public Goods, the Capability Approach, and Theories of Justice

    2026-07-19

    A neutral literature map that answers the normative question of why design should be democratized, using only established published sources. The Nordic lineage of participatory design shows process democratization as practice; Arrow and Hess & Ostrom's work on knowledge as a public good gives it an economic foundation. The capability approach of Sen and Nussbaum, Rawls's distributive justice, and Fraser's theory of recognition ground democratization at the level of desirability. Finally, Fischer's meta-design and Wenger's communities of practice show the redefinition of the expert's role and the conditions for sustained participation. 12 references.

  • The Many Dimensions of Design Value: A Literature Map from Instrumental to Relational and Recognitive Value

    2026-07-19

    A neutral survey, drawing only on established published literature, of the claim that design produces value across several dimensions rather than one. It ranges from instrumental usability (Norman 1988; Nielsen 1993), through learning from experience and meaning-making (Kolb 1984; Bruner 1990), the distinctive stance of designing (Cross 1982; Michlewski 2008), and relational value in communities of practice (Lave & Wenger 1991; Wenger 1998), to the ontological dimension of recognition (Honneth 1995). Practice theory (Bourdieu 1977; Schatzki 2002; Reckwitz 2002) offers a lens that reads these dimensions as socially formed practices rather than individual traits. 12 references.

  • The Epistemological Premises and Methodological Foundations of Design: A Literature Map of Wicked Problems, Abduction, and Set-Based Exploration

    2026-07-19

    The problems design confronts have no clear stopping rule, and the act of designing cannot avoid value judgment. Starting from this epistemological premise, this note maps reductionism and its limits, methodological pluralism, reflective practice and abduction, and set-based exploration through established published literature. Organized around Rittel & Webber's wicked problems (1973), it places Simon, Dewey, Churchman, Ackoff, Buchanan, Dorst, Feyerabend, Cross, Peirce, Schön, and Ward. 15 references.

  • The Democratization of Design and Ontological Designing: A Literature Map of Pluralizing the Paths of Value Realization

    2026-07-19

    Organized around the question of who designs and along which paths the value of that design is realized, this note maps the literature on the democratization of design as a neutral review. It brings together Manzini's design for social innovation (2015), ontological designing (the circle in which design creates a world that in turn creates us), traceable to Willis and to Winograd & Flores, Escobar's designs for the pluriverse (2018), Honneth's theory of recognition (1995), and Tronto's caring democracy (2013), under the single question of pluralizing the paths of value realization. 12 references.

  • Participatory Design and the Design of Collaboration: A Literature Map of Boundary Objects, Infrastructuring, and the Conditions of Participation

    2026-07-19

    A single map of the literature on how to design the participation of non-experts in design. It runs from participatory design rooted in Nordic labor movements (Ehn 1988; Robertson & Simonsen 2013), through the sociotechnics of an age when everybody designs (Manzini 2015), the generative tools and probes that engage non-designers (Sanders & Stappers 2008, 2012), the boundary objects that translate knowledge across groups (Star & Griesemer 1989; Carlile 2002, 2004), infrastructuring and agonism as the slow cultivation of collaborative ground (Ehn 2008; Karasti 2014; Björgvinsson et al. 2012), to design justice and the capability approach that interrogate the inequality of participation (Costanza-Chock 2020; Oosterlaken 2015). 17 references (0 Japanese, 17 English).

  • Activating Reframing in Design: Cognitive Mechanisms and Practical Methods

    2026-07-09

    Reframing -- the act of restructuring a problem's frame to open new solution spaces -- is a core competency of design cognition. Centering on Dorst's Frame Innovation (2015), this note examines the cognitive mechanisms of reframing (abduction, problem-solution co-evolution), eleven practical methods for activating reframing (analogical reasoning, How Might We, assumption surfacing, TRIZ contradiction analysis, speculative design, the 9-step Frame Creation process, and others), inhibiting factors (design fixation, anchoring, functional fixedness), and conditions at the team and organizational level (boundary objects, strategic use of surprise). Reframing is not an innate creative gift; it can be deliberately activated through structured methods and environmental design.

  • The Nexus of Design and Social Science: A Genealogy of Methods, Theories, and Institutions

    2026-07-09

    This note traces the genealogy through which design has absorbed methods and theories from the social sciences to form its own distinctive mode of knowledge. Beginning with Simon's sciences of the artificial (1969), continuing through Schon's reflective practice, Cross's designerly ways of knowing, and Buchanan's wicked problems, the trajectory extends to the importation of ethnography, participatory design, practice theory, actor-network theory, and activity theory. HCI, design anthropology, and STS have served as bridging fields, while contemporary movements such as design justice, transition design, and more-than-human design are reshaping the boundary between design and social science. Design's distinctiveness lies not in the appropriation of social-scientific methods but in the integrative judgment that envisions artifacts not yet in existence.

  • 'Design Is Not Craft' — Industry x Academia Roundtable

    2026-06-28

    A simultaneous roundtable on 'design ≠ craft' with three industry personas (firm/consulting/independent office) and three academic critics (theory/education/industry-career). Renders visible the industry side's triple deadlock of unbillable taste, human-hour model collapse, and practitioner reproduction breakdown alongside the academic side's arguments on the indispensability of embodied repetition and the historical contingency vs. conceptual necessity distinction, all as a divergence table. Records all rounds R1-R3.

  • The Relationship Between Design and Craft: Industry Intelligence

    2026-06-28

    An industry overview of the relationship between design and craft, collected across seven domains: cultural policy, the luxury industry, the Maker Movement, design firms and technology companies, Japanese monozukuri, software craftsmanship, and craft in the age of AI. Includes source tracking and position assessment.